You are here: Used Car Expert > BMW > BMW Z3 > BMW Z3 Reviews > Z3 Fails To Match Mx 5

Z3 fails to match MX-5 - BMW Z3 Car Review

Review

Added: 11 Aug 2008
Last update: 25 Dec 2009

PRICES for the BMW Z3 roadster are down to a much more affordable level.

It was BMW's answer to the Mazda MX-5 and MG F but although it is stylish and has the BMW stamp of quality it's not as exciting to drive as the Mazda and doesn't feel as poised as a sports car should be.

Six cylinder 2.8 and 3.0-litre engines give very good performance but the much more plentiful 1.9 is rather ordinary.

All Z3s were built in the USA, not Germany, and quality is occasionally not up to the same standard. Reliability is generally good though.

Main models are 1.9-litre with 118 or 140bhp and 2.0 or 2.2 six cylinder with 150 or 170. The 2.8 has 193 and the 3.0-litre 231bhp.

Refinement is good with the roof up but it's very blustery with the lid down with no wind deflector.

Ride is disappointingly unrefined but these cars handle safely and provide good roadholding and grip.

Interior

Seats are supportive and most people can find a comfortable position, but you feel as though you are sitting on, rather than in them.

The boot is a fairly good size, lockable cubbies provide storage but air-con is only standard with big engines.

FAST FACTS

BMW Z3

Price: Pay £6,400 for an '00 51-reg 1.9 base model, £8,300 for an '02 02-reg 2.2 Sport, or £10,300 for an '03 03 3.0 Sport

Mechanical: (1.9) 118bhp, 1,895cc, 4cyl petrol engine driving rear wheels via a 5spd manual gearbox

Max speed: 122mph

0-62mph: 10.1 secs

Combined mpg: 35

Insurance group: 14

Marks: 8/10

Main rivals: Honda S2000, Mazda MX-5

Words: Peter Hayward

Keywords: bmw, z3


Other BMW Z3 Reviews

Pivotal model for BMW (2012 May)
News
Relevance / rating:
BMW took a major step into the future with the introduction of the 'Neue Klasse' in the early 1960s.This was the first proper attempt by the Bavarian car maker to woo the middle management types. They had fielded the 700 but it was really not up to t... Pivotal model for BMW

BMW Open Weekend – save £520 a year (2008 May)
News
Relevance / rating:
With fuel prices passing the £5-per-gallon mark for the first time, the BMW UK dealer network is to stage a BMW EfficientDynamics Open Weekend where drivers of all makes and models of car will be able to take advantage of a free multi-point car... BMW Open Weekend – save £520 a year

BMW’s Canine Repellent Alloy Protection (2008 Apr)
News
Relevance / rating:
BMW has announced the first details of the new Canine Repellent Alloy Protection system. Designed to stop dogs fouling against the sparkling alloys of new BMW cars, the innovative Canine Repellent Alloy Protection system (C.R.A.P.) is the latest offe... BMW’s Canine Repellent Alloy Protection

Golf GTI or BMW 320cd (2008 Apr)
Q&A
Relevance / rating:
Hi I am looking to buy either a MK 5 Golf GTI or BMW 320 coupe diesel M Sport for about £15,000-£16,000. I do quite a few miles (about 15,000 a year) so was veering towards the BMW. However I am worried this car will... Golf GTI or BMW 320cd

Convertible car deals this summer (2008 Mar)
News
Relevance / rating:
Summer must be coming, as BCA Blackbushe is staging two special Live Online convertible sales on behalf of LloydsTSBautolease and Black Horse on the 14th and 28th April. The sales are expected to attract hundreds of buyers from all over the country ... Convertible car deals this summer

More BMW Z3 Articles:

12345...Last »

New search

Overall score:  (1)
Add your rating: